It had to happen… I’ve had a pretty sweet deal come to an end. For a few years, I’ve had a Chase card that earned 5% back on gas, groceries, and drugstores. I didn’t talk about it much, since you can’t apply for it anymore, so there wasn’t much point.

I got a letter that the program will change to 3% now. That change, coupled with my need to use an American Express card at Costco has had a domino effect on my cash back plan.

I always want to get the most cash back possible for all our spending, so I ran the numbers and calculated break even points between each card for each category that had tiers to break through. Here’s my new plan.

Cash Back Credit Card By Category

 
Purchase Credit Card Cash Back Notes
Gas American Express TrueEarnings Costco Business 5%
Groceries Chase Freedom 3.75% 3% Redeem $200 for $250 to get extra 0.75%
Wireless Service American Express SimplyCash Business 4%
Restaurants American Express TrueEarnings Costco 3%
Drugstores American Express Blue Cash 1%-5% If you spend over $6500 annually (all purchases combined). It works great if you play the drugstore game to get free after rebate items.
Online Discover More 5% Currently includes retailers such as Sears, Dell, Circuit City, Office Depot
Costco American Express TrueEarnings Costco 1% If you plan to spend less than $15,000 at Costco annually. Over $15,000 and the American Express Blue Cash wins.

Tips and Tricks

Spousal Tip

If you are like me, the only thing that will spoil the new plan will be trying to reteach your spouse which card to use where. My poor husband finally had it figured out too! Write where the card should be used in a black marker on the front of the card.

Business Cards

Want a business card, without a business? I explain how individuals can use Business Cards.

Discover Quarterly Promotion

Discover has quarterly promotions; sign up online with any Discover card. See the Discover cashback calendar. October 1 – December 31 has a 5% Cash back bonus on up to $400 on these purchases:

  • Grocery Stores
  • Restaurants
  • Movie Theaters
  • Movie Rentals

Action Plan

I have three of these cards currently, so I’ll put those into the rotation. I’ll plan on applying for the rest in a few weeks.

Did I miss any? I want to hit the highest cash back in every category; let me know if there’s a card out there that’s better than the ones I found.






We joined Costco! And we went there 5 times in 8 days! Here’s the catch with Costco, if you pay with credit, you need to use an American Express card. Lucky for me I keep a stash of credit cards handy for “emergencies” like this!

Why does it matter which card I use? Because I never like to give up free money! There’s one card that I keep just for cash back everywhere. It’s the Blue Cash Everyday® from American Express.

I already have one, so it’s naturally the one that I pulled out when I went to join Costco. I also use it whenever the American Express Wishlist comes around (which will be soon…. I’ll let you know!)

It’s also one of those cards that is perfect for people who just want to carry one card and forget about chasing all the various cash back offers.

Blue Cash Everyday® Card from American Express

Here are the details of the new Blue Cash Everyday® Card from American Express:

  • No annual fee, 0% intro APR on purchases for up to 15 months, flexibility to pay over time.
  • Get 3% at US supermarkets, up to $6,000 per year in purchases, 2% at US gas stations & select US dept stores, 1% on other purchases.
  • NO spend minimum, NO enrollment, and NO rotating rewards categories.
  • Get a $25 Referral Bonus for each friend or family member who is approved for the Card.

How the Cash Back Works

“Everyday Purchases” are Eligible Purchases made at U.S. stand-alone supermarkets, stand-alone gas stations and drugstores, in each case that are not departments of superstores or warehouse clubs.

We were spending about $9,600 per year on gas and groceries. So that’s about 2.3% using the Blue Cash Everyday® Card from American Express.

More Features of Blue Cash Everyday® Card

Unlimited cash rewards. This is a fantastic option for me. Every time I find a card with great rewards, my plan gets foiled by the limits. Not here!

Cash Tracker. They have a nifty online dashboard meter that shows you how much you’ve spent and how close you are to breaking through the tier.

Readers Love It. Whenever I write about credit cards, I hear about this one. Here are some recent comments:

  • I have American Express Blue Cash and in addition to the rewards they have great (and usually quick) customer service. – sara l
  • I’m with sara – you can’t beat American Express customer service. I have the Blue Cash and a Blue Rewards and I never use anything else (unless it’s a merchant who doesn’t take Amex…!) – Brip Blap

More Blue

In addition to the Blue Cash from American Express, you can also check out the Blue Sky Preferred Card from American Express where you can earn points for any airline, any hotel, any cruise or any car rental with no blackout dates, advance purchase requirements, hotel room restrictions, or travel restrictions.

Action Plan

Whenever I switch out some of our cards, it ends up being a domino effect. I’ll do a more thorough reevaluation of my stash of credit cards in the future. Stay tuned to see the other cards that I’m planning to use. Until then, I’ll be using my Blue Cash Everyday® Card from American Express.






Regular readers know that I’m a credit card arbitrage junkie. This one is for those of you that enjoy playing that game and want to take it to the next level, using business credit cards.

Why Are Business Cards So Useful?

They don’t report on your individual credit report. So you can use 90% of the limit on a bunch of cards and it won’t hurt you when you apply for more. It will appear as if they don’t even exist. This is clearly one of the most significant ways that I can carry over $200k in credit card balances and continue to be approved for more.

Do You Need a Business?

No, you do not need an incorporated business. You can open a business credit card as a sole proprietor. Most credit card companies allow you to open a business account as a sole proprietor using your name for the business name and your SSN. Before I had a business with a Tax ID number, I did this all the time. If it asked for my income, I just put down the amount of stuff I sold on eBay, which wasn’t that much. It doesn’t really matter though, because you can often reallocate your credit limits for bigger balance transfers.

In addition, some of the cards specify that “transferred balances must consist of business-related expenses.” Interpret that how you feel comfortable. I’ve always been honest with the companies and said what I was doing with the money and none of them had any problem with it.

Here are some 0% balance transfer business cards to get you started. If you want to make your plan of attack with the personal cards too, you can use the full list of 0% Balance Transfer Credit Cards.






UPDATE: The $25 bonus is no longer available for this card but it’s still one of the best cash rewards credit cards out there!

I keep the Best Cash Rewards Credit Cards updated regularly. One of the cards added after it was first published was the TrueEarnings® Card from Costco and American Express.

Costco Membership

In order to get the card, you must be a member at Costco. You’ll need need your Costco membership number to apply for the card. The card then works as both your credit card and your Costco Membership Card.

If you aren’t a member yet, you can sign up for a membership (or Business membership) online. Your membership number will be emailed within 48 hours.

TrueEarnings® Card from Costco and American Express

Details of the card:

  • 3% Cash back at US gas stations and on gasoline at Costco up to $4,000 per year in purchases, then 1%
  • 2% cash back at US restaurants; 2% cash back on eligible travel purchases, including at Costco; 1% cash back on other purchases, including at Costco
  • Terms and limitations apply; You will receive your cash back annually in the form of a reward coupon
  • The Two-In-One Card: it’s an American Express® Card and Costco membership card, with no annual fee for Costco members
  • Cardmembership offers access to benefits such as Global Assist and Purchase Protection* *Underwritten by AMEX Assurance Company
  • Terms and restrictions apply.
Apply for TrueEarnings Card from Costco and American Express

Costco Business Card

If you plan to use the card for gas, you might want to consider the TrueEarnings® Business Card from Costco and American Express. It offers 5% for buying gas. Although, there is not a free money sign up bonus with the business card.





It’s our last week of vacation and we’ll be heading home this weekend. In Free Money Friday fashion, here’s a vacation themed money saver for you: airline rewards credit cards!

I’m a big fan of frequent flier miles. We used miles for our honeymoon to Hawaii. What better way to travel, than for free?

As with all the credit cards I highlight, I’ll keep the list updated so you can bookmark it and check back in the future.

Find and compare all current credit card offers in our credit card directory.





It’s Free Money Friday!

Since we’re on vacation, I thought it would be appropriate to share the best travel and hotel rewards credit cards with you!

Find and compare all current credit card offers in our credit card directory.





Last week I brought up the story of a friend that needed help paying off debt. There were lots of great responses with different ways to get rid of the debt.

A recap of the situation (see the story for all the details):

  • Personal Line: $3,500 balance @ 15% – $7,000 limit
  • Credit Card #1: $2,300 balance @ 9.6% – $5,000 limit
  • Credit Card #2: $6,600 balance @ 8.5% – $8,000 limit
  • Credit Card #3: $1,900 balance @ 18% – $2,000 limit

He has $1510 available each month for payments and $9300 in company stock and upcoming bonus money available.

Here are some highlights of what readers have suggested:

1. Use a 0% Interest Card

Transfer all the credit card debt to a 0% interest card and decide on a set amount to pay each month. -John

Get a 0% credit card and put $14,300 on it. Pay himself $1166 each month into ING. Pay minimums on the card each month out of the ING account and pay the remainder off next year right before the 0% comes due. This will allow him to earn interest on the money, stop throwing away interest, and avoid selling company stock.

2. Make Equal Payments

Treat each account as if it was an installment loan and make equal monthly payments that should leave him with a zero balance at the end of four months. He can pay $902.51 each month on the personal line of credit, $586.55 a month on credit card 1, $1679.32 on credit card 2, and $492.95 on credit card 3. This is a total payment of $3661.33 each month. He ends up paying around $350 in interest on all the accounts over that time period. The main advantage to this method is that it’s fairly simple and everything is paid off at the same time.
– Jon

Five months of interest isn’t enough to sweat the details. The advantage is light at the end of the tunnel – a few months of serious ratcheting back then he’s done! It also seems silly to sell off stock in this short term plan, unless he absolutely cannot payoff otherwise and MUST be done by November. – Jay

3. Pay Highest Interest First

He should pay the minimum payments on the personal line and credit cards 1 & 2. He should sell his stock that he receives and use his bonus to pay off credit card 3 first. Then use the extra money to pay of the personal line, credit card 1, and finally credit card 2.

It’s best to pay off based on interest rate and not on balance or type. Why keep the stock? He won’t, on average, earn more on the stocks than he will be paying interest on those accounts. – Joshua

Use stock to pay off the personal line with the remaining $300 to credit card 4. Pay minimums to credit card 1 and 2 with the rest going to credit card 4. In August payoff credit card 4, and use the stock towards credit card 2 and 3. – deepali

4. Pay Smallest Balance First

Liquidate all non-retirement assets (including company stock and future bonuses) and throw it at the credit cards, in addition to any extra monthly money he can cash flow. Pay the credit cards off smallest balance to largest balance. – Frugal Dad

5. Avoid Future Debt

He should cut up all but one of his cards and decide to never carry a balance ever again. It sounds like he’s fairly intelligent so he should be able to do some ‘light’ reading to educate himself about debt and it’s compounding effects. – Brad

6. Subtract Charges Immediately

Once the cards are paid off, I would suggest on his rewards card that he wants to use for gas that when he charges an item to write it down in his check book (debit it) so that when the bill comes he has already accounted for the charges and the bill can be paid in full. – Dawn

7. Watch out for Tax Ramifications

One way would be to sell your stock, but you should be very sure of the tax ramifications of doing so before selling it. – Beating Broke in Debt Plan: My Dollar Plan Reader

My Thoughts

I’ll be back soon with a plan for him. All of these ideas are great, and I’m incorporating many of these points and some others. Stay tuned!





That’s what a reader, Maha, wanted to know. Maha sent me a note to let me know that trying to find out exactly what credit card arbitrage is all about, is like reading the middle part of the book without being able to find the beginning.

So I’ve realized that I talk just like I write! Sometimes I just start talking (or writing) about a subject without any introduction. In real life, people stop me and say, “What are you talking about?” So anytime I write an article, if it’s not clear, feel free to ask me more about it! Either leave a comment or send me an email. I love to share things I learn, but if they don’t make sense, then it’s not helpful.

Let’s get back to the credit card arbitrage.

What is Arbitrage?

From wiktionary, one of the definitions is:

Any market activity where a commodity is bought and sold quickly for a profit which far exceeds the transaction cost.

A Simple Example

Let’s say you are walking down the street and you see a sign that says, “Lemonade For Sale, $1.00.” As you walk to the next block, you see another sign, “Lemonade Wanted – Will Pay $2.00.” Of course, you think to yourself, I could make $1.00 if I buy the lemonade from the first stand and sell it to the second.

You walk to the first stand and buy all his lemonade – 50 cups for $50. You walk down the street and sell all 50 cups to the second stand for $100. You pocket $50 and go on your way.

This is an arbitrage situation. There’s a price differential between two markets that yields a profit. It’s easy to see in the lemonade example. There are real life situations where arbitrage situations exist, but sometimes they aren’t as clear as the two lemonade stands.

An Arbitrage Example

Here’s another example. A friend offers you $10,000 to use for one year any way you like. For the use of the money, the friend charges you $99. You realize that you can deposit the money in your ING account and earn 3%. You quickly realize that you could make over $300 in interest and after paying your friend $99, you will have made over $200 profit.

Credit Card Arbitrage

The above situation is exactly what is happening in credit card arbitrage. Instead of a friend, you are dealing with a company. Here’s how it works:

  1. Take a 0% balance transfer from the credit card company.
  2. Deposit the money in your savings account to earn interest.
  3. As payments are due, pay the bill with the money in your savings account.
  4. When the 0% offer expires, pay off the remaining bill with your savings account.

As long as the interest (less taxes) is greater than the transaction costs, you’ll have made a profit and taken advantage of an arbitrage situation.

Risks

Don’t get me wrong… the situation I described sounds too easy, it’s exactly the reason that the arbitrage exists. I’m guessing the majority of the people that try it slip up. They miss a payment, spend the money, forget to pay by the expiration date, etc. And the credit card companies make money, big money, on those mistakes.

Do I recommend it? No. Because it’s so risky and easy to mess up, I wouldn’t want to ever receive an email from a reader that made a mistake and lost a bunch of money!

Why do I talk about it if I don’t recommend it? I do have readers that take advantage of credit card arbitrage. It’s also fun to learn about new things even if you aren’t going to try it.

Arbitrage Extras and Twists

Scale. The larger the amount of money, the more that you can make. We made about $12,000 last year because we were running over $200,000 in arbitrage money. We also have about $1 million in credit limits to pull of such a big arbitrage plan.

How to get the money into your checking account? Some companies offer to send you a check. Others want to pay off a loan. I can easily use my heloc for this.

Use to pay off higher interest loans. We frequently run part of our mortgage at 0% interest rates to save even more money. If we were to ever run out of offers, we would put the money back on our heloc.

What happens at the end of the offer? When the 0% expires, I apply for a flurry of new cards and reallocate our credit limits for bigger balance transfers. It keeps the arbitrage going for another year.

Taking advantage of a spouse. I apply for all the credit cards in my name only. That enables me to run another set of arbitrage under my husband’s name!

Action Plan

We’re currently nearing the expiration on my cards. In the next few weeks, I’ll be “turning over” all my cards into new offers. I’ll write about some of the strategies that I use in more detail as they occur.





This list is updated regularly with the best no annual fee 0% balance transfer offers.





It’s credit card arbitrage turnover time! Wow, that is a mouthful. If you aren’t familiar with my credit card arbitrage here is some background information:

My cards are nearing the end of the promotional periods and I have to find new cards. Complicating the process this year is our refinance that is underway. It might get tricky, so this year won’t be a typical year for the rollover.

Just as I was preparing to tell you about it, I received some questions from a reader, Greg. The questions will help with some of the background before I get into the entire turnover process later this summer.

Do you worry about your HELOC being frozen? Would you be in trouble if that happened? Mine was frozen a couple of months ago and even though I was able to have it unfrozen, it was a royal pain.

As a matter of fact, my husband asked me the same thing recently. In general I don’t worry about it, because I have multiple personal lines of credit that I could use in a pinch if I had to.

We might actually have to close our HELOC to get the loan terms we want. Either way, during this turnover, I’ll be without my HELOC to use to store money. It’s a pain without it, but I think we could pull it off.

I understand how you get such large limits, but how do you get such large advances? I just opened another 0% card and completed a transfer. Since I have other Chase cards, I could easily raise the limit on this new card to $30k just by lowering other limits.

When you do this, are you then able to get them to process another and possibly larger transfer? I’ve come across some cards that have a limit of $10k on the amount they will transfer. You’ve obviously blown right past this.

Hmmmm, I haven’t run into the limit on the balance transfer amount before. One strategy I suggest is to raise the limit first, then do the balance transfer. That way if they are charging a fee, it will only be charged one time, effectively lowering your costs.

Also, I have often called and said that I would transfer more if they raise my limit, this seems to work in a few cases; maybe it would work when they give a limit on the transfer amount.

I’ve found the 0% no fee offers to be exceedingly rare. Most are 0% and a 3% balance transfer fee. Discover maxed the fee out at $50. Do all the 0% no fee offers come to you in the mail or do you search them out? Where?

I agree that many of the no fee offers have dried up. I looked in my notes from last year and found that we got no fees from various American Express, Citi, US Bank and Washington Mutual cards. We consistently found that Discover, Chase, Bank of America, and Bank Atlantic charged fees that usually maxed at $30, $50, $75, and $99.

I usually calculate what the fee is in terms of % rate. For example a $50 fee for a one year transfer on $25,000 works out to be 0.2%. (It’s actually a little off since you make a payment each month.) If the fee makes the interest rate to be more than 0.5%, I’ll pass on it. (This is why making the huge one time transfers help lower the effective interest rate.)

I used to keep all the offers that come in the mail before a big turnover, now I just primarily use online resources. I’ll highlight some of my list of target cards that I am planning on using in 0% balance transfer credit cards.

Are all credit cards in your name, your husbands, combo? All mine are in my name alone. I’ve thought about getting some in my wife’s name also.

Yes, I run both of our cards through arbitrage, but all are individual cards. In addition, every once in awhile I run some of the festivities on my moms cards. Here is why:

  • We can run turnovers at different times during the year.
  • If we find a great card with a good offer, we can use it twice, once for each of us.
  • Individual cards helps out on credit scores by not having us both hit by the same balance.

How staggered are these amounts? A simple average would say you have to refinance ~$20k per month. How much time do you spend tracking down and applying for another 0% card?

I do our applications once per year in our turnover. I pick out a bunch of cards, and apply all in one day. It usually takes about two hours to apply for them. When I complete my husband’s turnover, I use the same list of cards to save time. I pay him $5 per application to sit at the computer and apply for all of them. (Yes, I know we share money, but I don’t think he minds helping me out once in awhile.)

Since I turnover all the cards once per year, I don’t change them each month. To make the payments, I just pay out of the savings account or our HELOC. It’s much simpler that way.

How do you manage the actual arbitrage refinance? When you apply for credit card B to replace credit card A do you simply overpay the payoff amount on A and then ask them to send you the overpayment? Or do you send the money somewhere else and then payoff card A?

I never pay the cards directly. This is where I use HELOCs or personal credit lines. It’s much easier and there is no worry about missing a due date. I also avoid having to call to ask for refunds or to send up any red flags for payments that are too large.

Although, as I pointed out, I’ll be trying to run the turnover this year without my HELOCs because of our refinance. It will definitely be more challenging!

0% Credit Card Offers

To get started, I’m working on a target list of potential cards. Once I find a set of cards, I go in and look at the terms and check for: annual fee, balance transfer fee, 0%, and the number of months.

UPDATE: I’ve posted the list of 0% balance transfer credit cards I am considering.