Making Home Affordable Q & A

Posted by Madison on May 6, 2009

People have more questions than answers about the new Making Home Affordable program. A reader, Laura, recently sent me an email looking for help since all she could find was general information.

Unfortunately, I’ve found that many of the details aren’t on the general site. Instead they are buried in supplemental directives written for the lenders. Luckily, they are all available to us, so we can get the additional information we need.

Here are some of Laura’s questions about the loan modification. I’m sure that many of you considering the loan modification have some similar questions.

Loan Modification Q & A

We have about $10,000 in savings. Are we expected to use up all our savings before we will be considered for a loan modification?

Not necessarily. The loan modification program allows you to exclude an emergency fund, which they define as equal to three times your monthly debt payments. So if the $10,000 is your only cash reserves, then they will not require you to use it first.

We own two vehicles outright that are valued at around $10,000. Do we need to sell those before we apply?

Cash reserves are defined as cash, savings, money market funds, marketable stocks and bonds. Their is no mention of having to sell your vehicles before qualifying for a loan modification.

We have about $25,000 in retirement accounts. Do we need to raid those first before we can get a modification?

Retirement accounts are excluded from the calculation of cash reserves, so they will not expect you to use any retirement money before getting a loan modification.

I remember you had a post about you and your husband possibly applying for a loan modification (Would You Take a Loan Modification?).

But I would imagine that you are not having trouble paying your mortgage since you and your husband seem to be really smart with your finances. What would you write in your financial hardship letter? And do you know if it makes a difference that you leaving your past job was voluntary?

Thanks for the compliment. You are correct, we are not having trouble paying our mortgage. However, one of the hardship choices is a reduction or loss of income that was supporting the mortgage. It does not specify the cause of the lost income. I would reference that hardship reason, and be honest about the circumstances.

When I spoke to some of the servicers, it did not seem to matter that me leaving my job was voluntary (I can see light bulbs going on in people’s heads reading this!) However, three months after I left my job, the position was eliminated, so I would be sure to include that.

I’ll be writing more about our adventures with a possible loan modification in the future…. so stay tuned!

I am hoping to modify my mortgage because it currently takes up 51% of our gross income. We definitely qualify for a modification according to the numbers, but, we haven’t suffered any life changing event such as a job loss, loss of work hours, or sickness.

The hardship criteria is based on “are you having trouble paying your mortgage?” not necessarily a life event.

Here are all the types of hardship from the supplemental directive. You’ll notice that only the first four reasons reference a change of events. Options 5 and 6 reference a shortage of money, but no “life event” so there appears to be a lot of room in the hardship definition.

Hardship Affidavit

Every borrower and co-borrower seeking a modification, whether in default or not, must sign a Hardship Affidavit that attests to and describes one or more of the following types of hardship:

  1. A reduction in or loss of income that was supporting the mortgage.
  2. A change in household financial circumstances.
  3. A recent or upcoming increase in the monthly mortgage payment.
  4. An increase in other expenses.
  5. A lack of sufficient cash reserves to maintain payment on the mortgage and cover basic living expenses at the same time. Cash reserves include assets such as cash, savings, money market funds, marketable stocks or bonds (excluding retirement accounts and assets that serve as emergency fund – generally equal to three times the
    borrower’s monthly debt payments).
  6. Excessive monthly debt payments and overextension with creditors, e.g., the borrower was required to use credit cards, a home equity loan, or other credit to make the mortgage payment.
  7. Other reasons for hardship detailed by the borrower.

Making Home Affordable Lender Information

Want to find out all the other details about Making Home Affordable? Check out the materials and website that are targeted to the lenders:

You can get my latest articles full of valuable tips and other information delivered directly to your email for free simply by entering your email address below. Your address will never be sold or used for spam and you can unsubscribe at any time.


Comments to Making Home Affordable Q & A

  1. Hi Madison,

    Thank you so much for answering my questions in today’s article! I really appreciate this information as I have really been having trouble finding more specifics about the Home Affordable plan.

    I am going to call IndyMac today to see if they will talk to me about a refinance or a modification. We’ll see how that goes…. But I am willing to be persistant so they won’t get rid of me easily. 🙂

    I love your blog and read it daily. I have just recently become interested in personal finance and you blog always has such great information.

    Thank you again,



  2. Thank you, this information is very helpful.


  3. Thanks for the great info on loan modifications and the Making Home Affordable program. I’m sure this is quite helpful to the many people in foreclosure trouble.


  4. great post.


  5. This was a helpful posting. But I have an additional question regarding savings. What if you have over the “three times your monthly debt payments” in savings.

    What do they count as debt? Car loans, 2nd mortgage on primary house, credit cards??

    Thanks for your help!

    San Jose Gal

  6. FYI there is another directive that is the most up to date it’s the 09-05R It says you can have no more than 3 times you mortgage payment-NOT monthly debts in liquid assets. My question is do you know how my FICO score will be effected in laymans terms not the “reported as 09” or “reported as 28”


  7. I am wondering if the making home affordable modification is going to negatively impact credit scores. I heard they force you to pay the new (lower,) payment for several months before it is approved.

    Also the home must be your primary residence, but I rented my home last year and am moving back. My address on my tax return will not be my home. Will this cause disqualification?


  8. I have a tax lien on my house from an under payment in 2006. I am trying to get “Innocent Spouse Relief” as my husband passed away suddenly. Will this disqualify me from the Home Affordability Modification Program?

    Deanna Terrell

  9. I’m trying desperately to keep my home after 6 months of unemployment. Does anyone know if the makinghomeaffordable is real or just a scam? I called the number and spoke to a counselor or just told me that I didn’t qualify because I was unemployed and I needed to get a job before I would qualify. She tole me that I would receive some information in the mail which never arrived and told me to call her back with any other questions. I never received anything in the mail and left many messages with her voicemail which haven’t been returned. This certainly seems like a scam and just a PR gimmick. I have so far been unable to find anyone who will help me get a refinance (even at the current rates) for my home.


Previous article: «
Next article: »